Bradley Cooper Stanton Carlisle Cate Blanchett Dr. Lilith Ritter Toni Collette Zeena the Seer Willem Dafoe Clem Hoatley Richard Jenkins Ezra Grindle Rooney Mara Molly Cahill Ron Perlman Bruno Mary Steenburgen Mrs. Kimball David Strathairn Pete Mark Povinelli The Major Peter MacNeill Judge Kimball Holt McCallany Anderson Paul Anderson Geek #1 Lara Jean Chorostecki Louise Hoatley Jim Beaver Sheriff Jedediah Judd Clifton Collins Jr. Funhouse Jack Tim Blake Nelson Carny Boss David Hewlett Dr. Elrood Caleb Ellsworth-Clark Drunk #1 Dian Bachar Fee Fee the Birdgirl Troy James The Snake Man Jesse Buck Geek #2 Perry Mucci Hotel Manager Bill MacDonald Stanton’s Dad Dan Lett Deputy #1 Martin Julien Bus Station Shaving Man Natalie Brown Lilith’s Receptionist Tim Post Armed Guard #1 Will Conlon Armed Guard #2 Stephen McHattie Hobo #1 James Collins Train Yard Man Danny Waugh Piano Player Calvin Desautels Policeman Linden Porco Brofo the Small Dani Klupsch Geek Pit Patron Clyde Whitham Geek Pit Patron Romina Power Party Guest (uncredited) Keith Lukowski Security Guard (uncredited)