Amateur investigator Sierra Barter confronts a traumatic past and secrets that have plagued her family for generations. Sierra, her mother Shannon, and her grandmother Judy bravely pursue the truth about a mystery that could change their lives forever – was Jim Mordecai, their husband, stepfather, and step-grandfather a notorious serial killer?
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4c9ca/4c9ca2bbafef87e5f0ec565a0e6c8ecad451121b" alt=""
Digging Up the Past
Sierra Barter begins investigating her step-grandfather Jim by reaching out to family members, some of whom she had not spoken to in years. By interviewing Jim's ex-wives, children, and stepchildren, Sierra begins to put together a horrifying image of the man her step-grandfather was and the terror that he inflicted on his own family.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c5146/c5146b71aef1a62edc2c5c0354c37239b9fbfa44" alt=""
Eight Murdered Girls
Jim Mordecai was a revered teacher to most, but to others, he was a monster. Sierra looks deep within herself and questions if Jim's crimes may have escalated.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c6f20/c6f2097584801863c8d47897c0eb251f92730236" alt=""
The Devil and Jim Mordecai
Sierra's uncle shares a disturbing story further implicating Jim and a private investigator urges Sierra to find evidence. After Sierra searches through family storage, she learns the truth about a night that changed her family forever.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/cc47c/cc47c7694a304f4001cc9647e24fcc899ebe8f87" alt=""
Out of the Shadows
With the help of cutting edge technology, Sierra is able to build a DNA profile of Jim. Armed with the evidence she needs, Sierra hands her files over to law enforcement hoping to convince them to investigate.