Jessica Hynes Alana Kane Sean Delaney Gary Valentine William Martinez Jack Holden Alana Haim Rex Blau Dave Bautista Jon Peters Margaret Qualley Joel Wachs Cooper Hoffman Lance Brannigan Tom Waits Momma Anita Skyler Gisondo Jerry Frick Folake Olowofoyeku Lucille Doolittle Mary Elizabeth Ellis Mary Grady John Michael Higgins Matthew Harriet Sansom Harris Danielle Kane Joseph Cross Este Kane Danielle Haim Gale Este Haim Steve Maya Rudolph Brian Oakes Fegley Sue Pomerantz Isaac Bernauer Frisbee Kahill Ryan Heffington Mr. Jack Phil Hanley Wig Shop Brenda Nate Mann B. Mitch Reed Josh Zuckerman Airplane Brenda Yasushi Asaya Mioko Destry Allyn Spielberg Kimiko Yumi Mizui Kiki Page Megumi Anjo Kirk Gina Gershon Long Haired Freak Emily Althaus Armand Camron Jones Ray Will Angarola Guillermo Rogelio Camarillo Tim Eloy Perez Tiny Toes Girl James Kelley Tiny Toes Girl Sasha Spielberg Stage Mom Akiva Schaffer Stage Mom Anna Cordell Audience Dad Delaina Mitchell Director's Assistant Betsy Brantley Cop Tyler Young Police Dispatch (voice) Erica Sullivan B. Mitch Reed Assistant Andie Ju Reporter Colin Cunningham Number 12 Creep Larry Ervin Campaign Employee (uncredited) Jordan Drake Driver (uncredited) Jenny Slate Cop #2 (uncredited) Joe Alwyn Fred Gwynne / Herman Munster (uncredited) Jackie Moore Fair Volunteer (uncredited)