Dave Bautista Stanton Carlisle Kit Young Dr. Lilith Ritter Jordan Bullchild Zeena the Seer Tobey Maguire Clem Hoatley Rooney Mara Ezra Grindle Birva Pandya Molly Cahill Jonah Hill Bruno Neil Ross Mrs. Kimball Toni Collette Pete Richard Jenkins The Major James Gilbert Judge Kimball Aunjanue Ellis Anderson David Strathairn Geek #1 Mark Povinelli Louise Hoatley Ben Vereen Sheriff Jedediah Judd Ritchie Coster Funhouse Jack Philip Smithey Carny Boss Tom Mison Dr. Elrood Paul Anderson Drunk #1 Lara Jean Chorostecki Fee Fee the Birdgirl Tosin Morohunfola The Snake Man Caleb Ellsworth-Clark Geek #2 Dian Bachar Hotel Manager Jesse Buck Stanton’s Dad Perry Mucci Deputy #1 Bill MacDonald Bus Station Shaving Man Dan Lett Lilith’s Receptionist Joonas Saartamo Armed Guard #1 William Youmans Armed Guard #2 Angus Kennedy Hobo #1 Stephen R. Hart Train Yard Man Jeremy Ferdman Piano Player Ohene Cornelius Policeman Will Conlon Brofo the Small Calvin Desautels Geek Pit Patron Jared Abrahamson Geek Pit Patron Linden Porco Party Guest (uncredited) Dani Klupsch Security Guard (uncredited)